Scottish Pool
Topic: Scotlands Top Player

Moderated By: ChrisL
Aberdeen & District Pool League Forum Index
»» Scottish Pool
»» Scotlands Top Player

Please Register To Post

Author	Scotlands Top Player
ChrisL Home away from home Joined: 15-Sep-2004 Posts: 1519 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:48 1 - Jayson Shaw 2 - Darren Matthew 3 - Pat Holtz 4 - Pat McCarron 5 - Scott Gillespie 6 - Scott Ross 7 - Ross McInnes 8 - Danny Kinney 9 - Philip Craig 10 - Chris Corcoran Discuss! ----------------- CML Web Design Ltd Your complete web solution! Profile PM Quote
furrybeast Home away from home Joined: 11-Oct-2004 Posts: 4580 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:51 No mention of our current Scottish champion Mr Daniel? or even our current div one champ? [ This message was edited by: furrybeast on 2010-02-08 22:52 ] Profile PM Quote
thebigdog Just can't stay away Joined: 28-Jan-2010 Posts: 74	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:53 Good shout but i would change 5 with 3 [ This message was edited by: thebigdog on 2010-02-08 22:53 ] Profile PM Quote
ChrisL Home away from home Joined: 15-Sep-2004 Posts: 1519 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:54 Ah ok was trying to think who I had forgot. Ian on his day can beat all of the players in that list. I didnt quite make the top 10 lol! ----------------- CML Web Design Ltd Your complete web solution! Profile PM Quote
furrybeast Home away from home Joined: 11-Oct-2004 Posts: 4580 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:57 Bit of a pointless thread until all these players are competing together to be fair, but no doubt another thread that will rage on for 60 or 70 pages! Profile PM Quote
ChrisL Home away from home Joined: 15-Sep-2004 Posts: 1519 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:57 Not seem that much of Gillespie but Pat Holtz looked good on Sunday and I think has Scotland's best singles performances in the WEPF Worlds albeit not recently. PS. Steve Munro and James Pheely also would be in the top 4 if you count exiles. ----------------- CML Web Design Ltd Your complete web solution! Profile PM Quote
ChrisL Home away from home Joined: 15-Sep-2004 Posts: 1519 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 22:58 Whats your top 10 then George in an ideal world... ----------------- CML Web Design Ltd Your complete web solution! Profile PM Quote
AlanD Just popping in Joined: 31-Jan-2010 Posts: 4 From: Elgin	Posted: 2010-02-08 23:08 Can't believe Mike Clark and Raymond Mowat don't even get a mention! Both fantastic players in my opinion!! Profile PM Quote
furrybeast Home away from home Joined: 11-Oct-2004 Posts: 4580 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 23:18 Based on CURRENT form.. My GUESS (like I say, these players don't play together but I've seen enough of the top SPA players to make a reasonably informed judgment) 1 - Jayson Shaw 2 - Scott Gillespie 3 - Pat Holtz 4 - Pat McCarron 5 - Ross McInnes 6 - Darren Matthew 7 - Scott Ross 8 - Danny Kinney 9 - Ian Daniel 10 - Alex McDowell The next 20 or so would be much of a muchness, with Mike C, Phil Jnr and Chris C in there somewhere Profile PM Quote
furrybeast Home away from home Joined: 11-Oct-2004 Posts: 4580 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 23:20 Oops, forgot about Raymond too. Maybe slip him in at no10 Profile PM Quote
Scott Home away from home Joined: 29-Oct-2004 Posts: 637 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-08 23:31 What's the split sepf v spa?? Can we get a 5 a side on the go? Organisations stump up the prize fund!!! Pub rules so no arguing.... Profile PM Quote
cammy Home away from home Joined: 27-Feb-2008 Posts: 162 From: bankhead	Posted: 2010-02-09 01:29 Not a bad shout Scott i would love to see a SEPF select v SPA select Two legs home and away world rules up here and Blackball down there Think Chris is not far of the mark but i would swap 1 and 2 and Ian Daniel must be in around 8 Also Mike C has to be on the list best match player in the business [ This message was edited by: cammy on 2010-02-09 01:36 ] Profile PM Quote
springHeeledJim Home away from home Joined: 24-Oct-2004 Posts: 304 From: London	Posted: 2010-02-09 06:00 if you're counting exiles, then obviously SpringHeeledJim's the best bar none....then we have Darren Matthew and Ross McInnes...the rest of you are shit. Profile PM Quote
furrybeast Home away from home Joined: 11-Oct-2004 Posts: 4580 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-09 07:07 Gin on your cornflakes is a bad life choice Jim! Profile PM Quote
Darties Home away from home Joined: 06-Sep-2005 Posts: 400 From: Aberdeen	Posted: 2010-02-09 11:06 em from what Ive seen shaw is defo the best but its hard with daz as on his day he is amazing but he hardly plays that much now so not sure. My top 5 would be 1: Shaw 2: Gillespie 3: Dazza 4: Holtz 5: Patty/Scott Ross? I would love to see a two leg match but don't think that will ever happen. ----------------- Mon the Mill [ This message was edited by: Darties on 2010-02-09 11:08 ] Profile PM Quote